"A child's learning is the function more of the characteristics of his classmates than those of the teacher." James Coleman, 1972
Showing posts with label classroom cameras. Show all posts
Showing posts with label classroom cameras. Show all posts

Friday, July 25, 2014

Haslam's Secret Meeting at Ground Zero of Secret Classroom Camera Project

Last year we were able to uncover details of a Gates-funded student and teacher surveillance plan that gathered classroom video data and dumped it into a corporate Cloud for sharing among, who knows?

Now it seems Governor Haslam is meeting undercover with a group of "educators" in Washington County to find out "what works and what's not."  Wonder if the Gov plans to keep it all to himself once he finds out.  Apparently, the real educators of Washington County want to know when the Governor learns it:

What organizers are calling an outdoor gathering Friday in the parking lot of the Washington County School District’s central office is intended to shed light on a closed-door meeting taking place inside between the governor and selected school officials.

The meeting is one of 12 planned throughout the state, said Gov. Bill Haslam’s spokesman, Dave Smith, each closed to the public and news media to allow candid discussion between the governor and invited teachers and principals.

“The governor wants to hear from those in the room about what’s working and what’s not,” Smith said. “Common Core usually comes up, so do assessments and whatever else is on their minds.”

But the group of teachers and parents planning the counter meeting, which they emphasized is not a protest but a way for all of the stakeholders involved in the education process to encourage openness and transparency, said they’re worried they may not be accurately represented in the private meeting.
“We’re just concerned that there won’t be an open dialogue,” Washington County teacher Jenee 
Peters said. “The people going into this meeting to represent us are not our true representation.”

Susan Kiernan, the county district’s communications director, who said she would be setting up the meeting room, but was not invited to the discussion herself, said she believed the governor’s office made out the guest list.

Smith, of Haslam’s office, said the list of personnel for the meeting was recommended to the 12 districts by the Tennessee Organization of School Superintendents.

“They’ve taken the lead in inviting staff, because we want to keep it to a manageable-sized group,” Smith said.

According to Smith, Haslam has already attended eight such meetings in the state.

Earlier this week, one of those meetings in Bradley County drew criticism from elected school board members, who were shut out of the event by administrators, then informed after the fact by an email that the governor required that neither the school board nor the media be advised of the meeting.
Planning to be present at the outdoor meeting are several Washington County Board of Education members, who said they were likewise left off the guest list.

“We certainly should have been invited,” board member Phillip McLain said. “It’s a meeting about education in the state and we’re the Board of Education.”

McLain said he may not be able to attend the event, but school board member Jack Leonard confirmed his attendance and Peters said David Hammond had also given a verbal commitment to be present.

State Reps. Matthew Hill and Micah Van Huss, both in the midst of campaigning for re-election, are also planning to attend the open event.

“I think we all agree that we’re happy the governor is visiting Washington County,” Hill said from the Jonesborough street corner opposite the old courthouse, where he’d spent most of the day encouraging early voters to mark his name on their ballots. “What we’re doing isn’t adversarial. Both myself and Rep. Van Huss have been getting calls and emails from people worried about this meeting who think they should be included, and we don’t feel their requests are unreasonable.”

Peters said the attendees at the gathering aren’t planning to confront Haslam, but will give speeches outlining their concerns with the way the state Education Department has put in place reforms in recent years.

Teachers from Washington and Greene counties are expected there, as are their counterparts from Johnson City.

The outdoor gathering is scheduled for 3 p.m., about 25 minutes before the governor’s expected arrival for the closed meeting.

Thursday, June 26, 2014

Classroom Video Capture Project Proceeds With No Protocols for Security or Informed Consent

With Bill Gates's yesman, Dorsey Hopson, renewed for another term as non-educator-in-charge of Shelby County Schools, the pressure is on to expand the use of Microsoft's cloud-based technology to every aspect of schooling, from administering high stakes tests to video capture of children and teachers for teacher evaluation. 

Hopson is urging mandatory use of cameras in the classroom, even though there is no protocol in place and none planned to gain teacher or parent permission for these intrusive and insecure video captures, which will be uploaded to third party corporate servers with no guarantee of how the video will be used.
Superintendent Dorsey Hopson II said he thought that teachers ranked 1 or 2 on the district’s evaluation system—the lowest scores on a scale of 1 to 5—should be required to use Teachscape to improve their teaching practice. Mandating that the videos be required would require a change in board policy, Hopson said.

“We’ve been doing this from 2009,” Hopson said. “I think it was a good tool to introduce. But we have to be more strategic.”
Meanwhile, the Shelby County Schools will pay the Gates-connected corporation, Teachscape, $415,000 this year to advance the program across the district. With no informed consent procedures in place for parents, parents have little recourse but to sue to make sure their children's images in information are not recorded and archived by third-party corporations.

  Some propaganda from the Teachscape sight:


Tools for Video Capture and Sharing
With Teachscape's camera kits and apps for video capture and upload, educators can easily set up for and capture their own videos from the classroom.
Designed for easy video capture of small-group work, meetings, or the classroom, the optional Mini Tablet Kit and Mini Camera Kit pair with educators' own Apple devices (sold separately).

Capture and upload apps are included with Teachscape Learn and Teachscape Reflect so educators can transfer their videos to a secure platform to share, comment on, score, and create clips of videos to build their own libraries of best practices. 

Friday, February 14, 2014

Part 4: Classroom Video Camera Project . . . Where The Cameras Are in Over 120 TN Schools

Part 4: Classroom Video Camera Project . . . Where The Cameras Are in Over 120 TN Schools

Denise Wilburn and Jim Horn

After two weeks of waiting, the State of Tennessee today released the list of school districts and schools in the state that are participants in the video data gathering project sponsored by the Gates Foundation in the amount of $3.2 million.  

ThereNow.com, a Utah company with ties to the Gates Foundation, has been named as the primary vendor and storage site for all video data and accompanying notes.  See Parts 1, 2 and 3 of this report.

It is now clear the state has adopted not only the Common Core Standards and the PARCC assessments but has also accepted the Gates evaluation plan including:
·  Value added testing (TVAAS)
·  Student surveys
·  Video-recorded lessons

These are all part of the MET study that has been critiqued by leading researchers in educational assessment.  There are apparently many problems with the study and Gates’ resulting conclusions based on this study.

Lots of questions must be asked to make sure that children are protected .  Adapt them to your own community (see list of schools below), and be at the next Board meeting to ask them.  If you can’t attend, send them to your local newspaper:

1.     How did the video component of the Gates’ evaluation plan come to Washington County?  The second Annual Report on Teacher Evaluation says “Sixty wide-angle video cameras were deployed to 55 schools during the 2012–13 school year and nearly 100 more will be deployed during the 2013–14 school year,” but it does not say where they would be deployed.  Now we know.
2.     Why did we find out about the cameras in Washington County from WCEA instead of our individual building administrators or central administration?
3.     What information will be shared with teachers about the videotaping process and the data collected?
4.     How much input will teachers have into this process?
5.     Who will see these videos?  Teachers only? Teachers and principals only?  Teachers, principals, and central office staff?  Gates’ staff of video reviewers? Third parties that use the data to develop educational products?
6.     Did state and local governmental bodies approve the collection, storage, and transfer of video and audio data from classroom interactions?  If so, which ones?
7.     Will these videotapes be uploaded to the Gates’ research data storage and retrieval site?  It looks like Rep. Bill Dunn has some concerns about this in HB1549 (http://legiscan.com/TN/text/HB1549/2013).
8.     Will there be consent forms for teachers to sign that explain the full extent of the purposes for and uses of the videotapes?
9.     How will parents be informed that their children may be videotaped for transfer and storage by third parties for research purposes?  Will they sign consent forms?  What if they do not wish their children to be videotaped?
10.  What protocols will be established and followed to guarantee responsible conduct of research, per requirements of U. S. Government Statutes, Regulations and Policies, as well as State of Tennessee statutes and pending legislative initiatives?
11.  Does the use of these videos violate any privacy, confidentiality or other policies that protect teachers and students?  Will we receive assurances about this in writing?  
12.  Will these videotapes be part of this year’s evaluation process?  If not this year, then when?
13.   Will these cameras be used at other times besides the designated evaluation times?

14.  Can these videotapes be subpoenaed from legal purposes?

District
ThereNow Schools with Cameras
Achievement School District
Corning Elementary School
Achievement School District
Frayser Elementary School
Achievement School District
Westside Middle School
Achievement School District
LEAD at Brickchurch
Achievement School District
Gordon Science and Arts Academy
Achievement School District
Cornerstone Prep Memphis
Alcoa
Alcoa Middle School
Alcoa
District-wide
Alcoa
Alcoa High School
Bristol
Avoca Elementary School
Cannon County
Auburn Elementary
Cannon County
East Side Elementary
Cannon County
Short Mountain Elementary
Cannon County
West Side Elementary
Cannon County
Woodland Elementary
Cannon County
Woodbury Grammar
Cannon County
Cannon County High School
Carter County
Unaka Elementary School
Carter County
Happy Valley Middle School
Carter County
Cloudland Elementary School
Carter County
Valley Forge Elementary School
Carter County
Happy Valley High School
Carter County
Hunter School
Carter County
Unaka High School
Carter County
Hampton High School
Carter County
Cloudland High School
Carter County
Happy Valley Elementary School
Carter County
Keenburg School
Carter County
Hampton Elementary School
Carter County
Siam School
Carter County
Little Milligan School
Chester County
Chester County High School
Claiborne County
Midway Elementary School
Crocket County
Crockett County High School
Crockett County
Maury City Elementary
Crockett County
Crockett County Middle School
Crockett County
Crockett County High School
Crockett County
District-wide
Etowah
Etowah Elementary School
Fentress County
South Fentress Elementary School
Fentress County
York Elementary School
Fentress County
York Elementary School
Fentress County
Pine Haven Elementary School
Fentress County
Allardt Elementary School
Franklin SSD
Moore Elementary School
Haywood County
Haywood Jr. High School
Haywood County
Haywood High School
Hickman County
East Hickman High School
Humboldt
Stigall Primary School
Lauderdale County
Lauderdale Middle School
Lauderdale County
Halls Elementary School
Lauderdale County
Halls High School
Lauderdale County
Halls Junior High School
Lauderdale County
Ripley Elementary
Lauderdale County
Ripley High School
Lauderdale County
Ripley Primary
Lexington
Lexington Middle School
Lexington
Paul G. Caywood Elementary School
Madison County
Rose Hill Middle School
Madison County
Northeast
Maury County
J. E. Woodard Elementary School
Morgan County
Central Middle School
Oak Ridge
Woodland Elementary School
Oak Ridge
Glenwood Elementary School
Oak Ridge
Linden Elementary School
Oak Ridge
Willow Brook Elementary School
Oak Ridge
District-wide
Obion County
Lake Road Elementary School
Putnam County
Putnam Co Adult High School
Putnam County
Algood Elementary School
Putnam County
Algood Middle School
Putnam County
Avery Trace Middle School
Putnam County
Baxter Elementary School
Putnam County
Burks Elementary
Putnam County
Cane Creek Elementary School
Putnam County
Capshaw Elementary School
Putnam County
Cookeville High School
Putnam County
Cornerstone Middle School
Putnam County
Jere Whitson Elementary
Putnam County
Monterey High School
Putnam County
Northeast Elementary School
Putnam County
Park View Elementary
Putnam County
Prescott South Elementary School
Putnam County
Prescott South Middle School
Putnam County
Sycamore Elementary School
Putnam County
Upperman High School
Putnam County
White Plains Academy
Roane County
Oliver Springs High School
Tipton County
Austin Peay Elementary School
Tipton County
Atoka Elementary School
Tipton County
Brighton Elementary School
Tipton County
Brighton Middle School
Tipton County
Crestview Elementary School
Tipton County
Covington High School
Tipton County
Covington Integrated Arts Academy
Tipton County
Crestview Middle School
Tipton County
Drummonds Elementary School
Tipton County
Munford Elementary School
Tipton County
Munford High School
Tipton County
Brighton High School
TNDOE
State-wide
Trousdale County
Trousdale County Elementary School
Trousdale County
Jim Satterfield Middle School
Trousdale County
Trousdale County High School
Trousdale County
Trousdale County Elementary School
Warren County
Warren County Middle School
Washington County
Boones Creek Elementary School
Washington County
Boones Creek Middle School
Washington County
Daniel Boone High School
Washington County
David Crokett [sic] High School
Washington County
Fall Branch Elementary School
Washington County
Gray Elementary School
Washington County
Jonesborough Elementary School
Washington County
Jonesborough Middle School
Washington County
Lamar Elementary School
Washington County
South Central Elementary School
Washington County
Sulphur Springs Elementary School
Washington County
University School
Washington County
West View Elementary School
Washington County
Asbury School
Washington County
District-wide