"A child's learning is the function more of the characteristics of his classmates than those of the teacher." James Coleman, 1972

Monday, July 09, 2007

The Charter Cheats and the Haqq

The SF Chronicle has the goods on Uprep, another one of those high-flying charter miracles whose results are, indeed, too good to be true:

University Preparatory Charter High School in East Oakland bills itself as a high-end academy where students attract recruiters from the nation's top universities.

Photos of young scholars in caps and gowns grace its Web site above the names of colleges that accepted them -- Oberlin, Dartmouth, Pomona, Whitman.

But that bright image belies a grim truth: Someone at this inner-city public school, also known as Uprep, is cheating.

The state Department of Education has just concluded for the second year in a row that one or more adults interfered with state-required testing at the school. This spring, state investigators seized copies of 2005 tests being illegally used to prepare students for the 2007 exams.

State rules require that test booklets be turned in at the conclusion of testing each year because many exam questions remain the same. At Uprep, someone photocopied the 2005 test books and kept them.

"That's a fairly significant security breach," said Deb Sigman, testing director for the state Department of Education. "California statute specifically prohibits any preparation that is specific to this test."

Last year, investigators found that someone changed hundreds of test answers from wrong to right before they were sent to the state.

In a rare move clamping down on a charter school's autonomy, the state is ordering the Oakland school district to take over Uprep's testing, Sigman said.

Now, eight former teachers assert in a 27-page report to state and local education officials that a culture of cheating exists at the school. And they say it's done at the top level.

The teachers claim:

-- Students' grades are frequently falsified.

-- Course titles don't always match the easier content tested.

-- Low-scoring students are barred from taking state-required exams in an attempt to keep them from lowering the school's scores.

-- Discipline is arbitrary and intimidating.

Just as stunning is the teachers' assertion of who is responsible for the alleged misconduct: the director, Isaac Haqq, Uprep's founder and most fervent cheerleader.

Haqq denies doing anything wrong.

"We're not trying to cheat," Haqq said. "We never have. It's easy to blame us."

He dismissed the teachers' report as the work of disgruntled former employees, some of whom he fired.

More than 470 students attend the school that Haqq, a former Pasadena city councilman, founded in 2001 inside the tattered Eastmont Mall on Bancroft Avenue in East Oakland. Haqq calls his school -- where classes are taught on an 11-month-long annual schedule -- "the front line of the civil rights movement" and sees it as an academic rescue mission for some of the Bay Area's most troubled teens.

"We're a great school," Haqq told The Chronicle.

In June, 100 Uprep seniors walked the graduation stage. The number of graduates was far lower than the 365 seniors the school claimed last fall. Even so, 40 of those graduates -- most from the low-income neighborhoods near the school -- are headed to college in the fall.

"It's kick-ass what I'm doing!" Haqq said.

But doubts are surfacing, and the Oakland Unified School District is investigating the teachers' allegations.

"We take this very seriously as the charter's authorizer," said Kirsten Vital, chief of community accountability for the Oakland schools, which has the power to close the autonomous public school but not to fire anyone.

Meanwhile, Uprep teachers aren't the only ones complaining. A counselor from Oakland's Skyline High told The Chronicle that some of Skyline's worst students suddenly became high-scoring scholars after they transferred to Uprep.

"It's appalling," said counselor Helen Wolfe-Visnick. "I don't know what they're doing over there."

She told of one Skyline senior who for years earned D's and F's. Last fall, he transferred to Uprep, where he not only earned A's and B's, but took 16 classes in a single semester -- including three English and three science classes.

He returned to Skyline this spring, and the D's and F's also returned, except for B's in two art classes. And he graduated, said Wolfe-Visnick, because she was obligated to count the suspicious Uprep grades.

"It's terrible!" she said. "It's so unethical. It's almost like we're just as guilty as Uprep is for accepting this."

Her experience bolsters one of the Uprep teachers' most serious allegations: that someone is falsifying grades.

In the report, former English teacher Kateri Dodds told of a sophomore who had "several of his failing grades changed to C's the first semester. He showed me his report card and told me the grades he should have gotten, according to his most recent progress reports: F's."

Dodds quit in May. . . . .


  1. Anonymous6:03 PM

    I can't believe that stuff like this happens. How can we expect kids to be honest and achieve well if adults are undermining the system? I am left dumbstruck.

    So where do you go to find good schools for troubled teens? A quick search brought up www.eprogramsearch.com. They have a bunch listed, but is there some central location where you can find out if they've had any offenses like this?

  2. Anonymous3:11 PM

    I worked at this school about 5 years ago and it was horrible. The guy who ran the school actually hired a teacher WITHOUT A BA! I called the Oakland School District and they didn't even seem to care. It was very sad.